Friday, December 23, 2011

Fate of Seal trade "sealed"?


Recent reports of a Russian ban on imports of seal products brought to the fore issues of trade, animal rights and domestic policy space in the context of WTO obligations. The reports referred to a document on the WTO website that indicated a trade ban. I was not able to get my hands on this document from the website.

A harp seal lays on a ice floe in the Gulf of St. Lawrence Saturday March 25, 2006. (THE CANADIAN PRESS / Jonathan Hayward)

The Globe and Mail reported that a Russian ban would severely effect the Canadian seal industry:
"Russia and two of its neighbours have informed the World Trade Organization that they are banning the import and export of harp seal pelts – a move that animal-rights activists are celebrating as the death knell of Canada’s commercial seal industry."

The reports of the ban have been covered herehere and here. The supporters of the ban claim that this would bring the cruel, inhuman slaughter of clubbing seals for their fur to an end. Canadian Government and others opposing the ban claim that the methods used are scientific and humane and that the ban could adversely affect communities that rely on this trade for their livelihood. In terms of trade, this is a major blow to Canadian seal exports as Russian markets constitute 90% of the market share of seal exports from Canada.

The European Union has already passed regulation banning seal trade which has been challenged by Canada in the WTO in 2009. 

The European Union justified the ban accordingly:

"The European Union is concerned about the animal welfare aspects of the seal hunt. Doubts have been expressed about some of the methods used for hunting seals, such as shooting, netting and clubbing, that can cause avoidable pain and distress. Several EU Member States were considering, or had already introduced, national legislative measures to ban the import and use of seal skins and seal products. In the light of these concerns, on 16 September 2009 the European Parliament and the Council adopted a Regulation banning the trade in seal products in the European Union. It applies to seal products produced in the EU and to imported products. The aim of the Regulation is to ensure that products derived from seals are no longer found on the European market. The Regulation was published in the Official Journal on 31 October 2009, entering into force on 20 November 2009. The ban itself entered into force 9 months after the entry into force of the Regulation (i.e. 20 August 2010).

The Regulation foresees limited exemptions to respect the fundamental economic and social interests of Inuit and other indigenous communities. It also contains exceptions for goods derived from seals for personal and non-commercial use and for goods derived from seals hunted for the sole purpose of the sustainable management of marine resources on a not-for profit basis and for non-commercial reasons."

The Regulation relating to the ban on imports of seal products states that "the placing on the market of seal products shall be allowed only where the seal products result from hunts traditionally conducted by Inuit and other indigenous communities and contribute to their subsistence." 
Hence, all commercially exploited seal products are banned in the European member countries. Thus, barring the seal products from traditional communities, imports of seal products obtained by all other methods (whether scientific, humane or inhuman) are banned in the European Union. Recognising that there may be methods of humane killing of seals for obtaining their products, the European Union regulation laid down that "although it might be possible to kill and skin seals in such a way as to avoid unnecessary pain, distress, fear or other forms of suffering, given the conditions in which seal hunting occurs, consistent verification and control of hunters’ compliance with animal welfare requirements is not feasible in practice or, at least, is very difficult to achieve in an effective way, as concluded by the European Food Safety Authority on 6 December 2007."

Iceland joined Canada in opposing this ban asserting that though the Intuit community (local indigenous community) practices were exempt from the ban, in reality they were effected.

Animal welfare groups like this one and this one have for long protested against the trade in seal products and have claimed victory on the latest ban by Russia as a step in the right direction. PETA also has high profile stars to campaign against the trade.


The European Union ban and now the Russian ban has made Canada look for markets elsewhere. And where else but the largest growing market - China.

It was reported that the Chinese market promises to provide the much needed relief to the Canadian seal industry in view of the latest ban in Russia which hitherto constituted 90% of the Canadian seal trade.

The issue of the ban on seal products raises many interesting questions:
1. Whether the ban of this nature is violative of a member country's WTO obligations under the TBT and GATT Agreements? Is it not a barrier to trade?
2. Are issues of animal welfare, environment protection and other non-trade considerations germane and permissible barriers to trade? Would it lead to imposition of "subjective" barriers to trade? Are there universal, international standards in this regard?
3. Do the WTO agreements, which focus on promoting trade and reducing barriers to trade, permit considerations of animal rights to determine permissible policies?
4. How should the WTO decide in a case of the right to livelihood of communites engaged in trade vis a vis a ban based on certain principles of animal welfare and environment protection?
5. Are the principles of human rights, labour rights, animal rights, environment concerns relevant in the rule-based determination of right and obligations of the WTO?
6. With multiple stakeholders involved in this issue (in the case of Canada, the commercial seal traders, intuit community members, consumers, animal right activists and the Government of Canada), whose interest does the Canadian Government represent at the WTO? Is that decision the prerogative of the Canadian Government? This issue is symptomatic of many disputes that arise in the WTO.









48 comments:

Anonymous said...

Use Rubber Mulch For Making A Safe Kid's Playground Is Shredded Rubber Mulch Good For Organic Gardens

Feel free to surf to my web page www.leb4host.com
my website: milwaukee tree nursery

Anonymous said...

How do I change firefox from remembering my facebook info?


Feel free to visit my homepage :: razere.com
Here is my website paxil lawsuit settlements

Anonymous said...

What blogging site am i able to start a blog and actually get viewers or subscribers?


My blog post ... vaginal mesh compensation
My web page :: transvaginal mesh lawyers

Anonymous said...

In a little over a week, the Hanssen case will be re-told on the silver screen in a new film
called Breach. It stars Chris Cooper as Hanssen and and Ryan Philippe
as FBI rookie Eric O'Neill, who helped bring Hanssen in. Samsung unveils Galaxy S III phone with quad-core, Android ICS http://tinyurl.com/amtx2ln The report warned that 'the risk of violence could increase both at home
and abroad as the film continues to gain attention', according to ABC News. These databases are responsible for finding the name and address of the owner. This information is cross referenced with the outside other electronic database across the region. Reverse cell phone directory enables one to find the name and address of the owner. Others may give the exact location by the use of maps, other phone number accounts as well as the duration that the phone numbers have been in use. Others are capable to telling one other public records and information.
Here is my weblog reverse phone lookup

Anonymous said...

Hello just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know
a few of the images aren't loading properly. I'm not sure why but I think its a linking issue.
I've tried it in two different internet browsers and both show the same results.

Feel free to visit my web site: American Health Advantage Review
my site - American Health Advantage Scam

Anonymous said...

Tips on how to stop importing blogs on facebook?

'Stop importing' button is not really found.
?

Visit my page - http://www.gradyandkatie.com/guestbook/yapgb.php
Also see my page :: wiki.gdite.mx

Anonymous said...

If you are going for most excellent contents like I do, just go to see
this website everyday for the reason that it presents quality contents, thanks

My web-site Root Canal

Anonymous said...

I need to to thank you for this wonderful read!! I absolutely enjoyed every little bit of it.
I have got you book marked to look at new stuff you post…

Feel free to visit my homepage - what does a root canal cost

Anonymous said...

I know this if off topic but I'm looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get set up? I'm assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny?
I'm not very web smart so I'm not 100% positive. Any suggestions or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos

Take a look at my web site - dental insurance plans

Anonymous said...

Mulch Needed For Tree Woolly Pod Vetch Living Mulch Nitrogen Fixer

Feel free to visit my web blog - tree nursery ozaukee county

Anonymous said...

Good day! Do you know if they make any plugins to
protect against hackers? I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard on.

Any tips?

Feel free to visit my website :: socialenginezzz.com

Anonymous said...

Wonderful blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo
News. Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Cheers

Check out my webpage http://en.wikipedia.org

Anonymous said...

I'm a writer and I would love to have people's opinions on my work.

Does anyone know a good blogging sites?. Twitter is not really
a blogging site and the only way people see your focus on twitter is if they follow you.
Twitter and Facebook aren't answers which i is searching for. Thank you for your input..

Here is my site; www.mokchon-kimjungsik.org

Anonymous said...

Louis Vuitton slode [url=http://www.louisvuittoncuir.fr]sac Louis Vuitton[/url] gjxkxe sac Louis Vuitton [url=http://www.vuittonsachomme.fr]Louis Vuitton Pas Cher[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hello there! Do you use Twitter? I'd like to follow you if that would be ok. I'm definitely
enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

My web site ... watch tv online

Anonymous said...

sac Louis Vuitton [url=http://www.louisvuittonsac20133.fr]Louis Vuitton sac[/url] ohqzpr [url=http://www.louisvuittonpascher2.fr]sac Louis Vuitton[/url] mnhfqy

Anonymous said...

sac Louis Vuitton [url=http://www.louisvuittoncuir.fr]Louis Vuitton sac[/url] jopggh Louis Vuitton [url=http://www.louisvuittonsac20133.fr]sac Louis Vuitton[/url] gpmtsm

Anonymous said...

Whats up very cool web site!! Man .. Excellent .. Superb .
. I'll bookmark your web site and take the feeds also? I'm happy to seek out so
many helpful info here within the post, we need develop extra strategies on this regard, thanks for sharing.
. . . . .

Feel free to visit my web blog ... jinbo.net

Anonymous said...

You actually make it appear so easy with your presentation however
I to find this topic to be really one thing which I think I'd by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and very wide for me. I am having a look forward on your subsequent post, I'll
try to get the hold of it!

Visit my web page buy solar cells online uk

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchels UKCambridge Satchel rkay Cambridge Satchel Salecambridge satchel uk yfie

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel Companycambridge satchel bag ejzx the cambridge satchelcambridge satchel company wsey

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel OnlineCambridge Satchel Sale bfre Cambridge Satchel Onlinethe cambridge satchel tkyo

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel UKCambridge Satchels UK akni cambridge satchel bagCambridge Satchels UK qkfv

Anonymous said...

Hi i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anywhere, when i
read this paragraph i thought i could also create comment
due to this brilliant piece of writing.

Feel free to visit my homepage how to buy solar cells wholesale

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel CompanyCambridge Satchel Online yjbl Cambridge SatchelCambridge Satchel rhja

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchelcambridge satchel company czab Cambridge Satchel SaleCambridge Satchel Sale vyfo

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel OnlineCambridge Satchel gtmb Cambridge Satchel SaleCambridge Satchel leuz

Anonymous said...

cambridge satchel bagCambridge Satchel wxok Cambridge Satchel Salecambridge satchel bag ixnn

Anonymous said...

Howdy very nice blog!! Man .. Beautiful .. Superb .
. I will bookmark your website and take the feeds additionally?
I am satisfied to find numerous useful information
here within the submit, we need work out extra strategies in
this regard, thank you for sharing. . . . .
.

Feel free to surf to my homepage; stretch mark creams

Anonymous said...

Awesome issues here. I'm very glad to see your article. Thank you a lot and I am having a look forward to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a e-mail?

Also visit my blog stretch mark lotion

Anonymous said...

cambridge satchel bagcambridge satchel uk vaaa Cambridge Satchel Onlinecambridge satchel company umbj

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel SaleCambridge Satchel Sale yjin Cambridge Satchel SaleCambridge Satchel dkqi

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel OnlineCambridge Satchel Company jrgm Cambridge SatchelCambridge Satchel Sale tyuh

Anonymous said...

the cambridge satchelCambridge Satchel irin cambridge satchel companycambridge satchel uk fyxg

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel CompanyCambridge Satchel Online gaus Cambridge Satchel UKCambridge Satchel Online ijaf

Anonymous said...

Cambridge Satchel UKCambridge Satchel wlsp Cambridge Satchel SaleCambridge Satchels UK wjtg

Anonymous said...

Hi there, i read your blog from time to time and i own a
similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam remarks?

If so how do you prevent it, any plugin or anything you can recommend?
I get so much lately it's driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.

Feel free to surf to my page buy kyocera solar panels

Anonymous said...

I read this article completely concerning the resemblance of newest
and earlier technologies, it's awesome article.

Also visit my web-site www.showmyname.ru

Anonymous said...

Does your website have a contact page? I'm having trouble locating it but, I'd like
to shoot you an email. I've got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it develop over time.

Also visit my site - Http://konannavi.org

Anonymous said...

Can I simply just say what a comfort to discover
an individual who actually understands what they are discussing online.
You definitely understand how to bring an issue
to light and make it important. More and more people really need to
look at this and understand this side of the story. I was surprised that
you aren't more popular given that you certainly possess the gift.

Feel free to surf to my page :: http://www.itscholarshipforum.com/Groups/ranger-rd6-custom-kydex-sheath

Anonymous said...

http://louis-vuitton-handbags.finniwolf.comthe architects alter the handbag in a small concept generallyhttp://louis-vuitton-bags.finniwolf.com as fundamental as upgrading the initials used on the. for example, Louis Vuittinside has a special LV his / her wholesale handbags, Louis Vuitton belt

Anonymous said...

I always spent my half an hour to read this website's posts everyday along with a mug of coffee.

my blog post - http://wiki.democratie.free.Fr/

Anonymous said...

Sometimes seasons reasons some shoes can be[url=http://niketrainersuksale.webeden.co.uk]http://niketrainersuksale.webeden.co.uk[/url]
temporarily do not possess the possibility[url=http://tomscanadaoutlet.snappages.com]Toms Canada[/url]
endure such shoes we've got to[url=http://addnikecanadastore.snappages.com]Nike Shoes Online[/url]
rightly placed both of them within your[url=http://louboutintrainersuk.blog.co.uk]Christian Louboutin Outlet[/url]
set upright position in order to sidestep dispensable damage of shoes[url=http://salelouisvuittonuk.webeden.co.uk]Louis Vuitton Shoes[/url]

If your insole can be so rotten, as opposed to could do with a docile bracken and splash gently scrub. Is noted that, don't use chemical soaps cleaning, or they'll root the insole the arise of fabric off.[url=http://shoppradabagsuk.webeden.co.uk]Prada Outlet[/url]

Anonymous said...

Seven states, including 54 Kentucky counties. They were featured on a recent episode of The
Doctor's. The successful candidate should be a self-sustaining Judaism that can survive and thrive without exclusive dependence texas nurse practitioner on theology and ritual. Every single texas nurse practitioner time she gets a cold she doesn't eat for a week.

Eventually, my husband and I got her contact information.
While the problem continues to grow, my pregnancy will no longer be bankrupting the government.


Here is my weblog - neonatalnursepractitionersalary.us

Anonymous said...

I'm curious to find out what blog system you have been working with? I'm experiencing some small security
problems with my latest blog and I'd like to find something more safe. Do you have any solutions?

My blog; fat loss factor cost

Anonymous said...

No force marketing and advertising chwilówki Business Failures

Anonymous said...

Prescription drug expenses are normally protected for a chosen portion from the costs. The total amount will depend on the particular state program or maybe the employer's health program. If you discover that the protection is not plenty of, you can buy additional insurance coverage in reducing the costs of prescriptions. Also, there are medical experts plus unique clinical gear that may not be covered below provincial or company programs. You can get a medical health insurance strategy from the private supplier that includes specialist plus particular medical related products insurance coverage. chwilówka znajdz In case a home owner selects to use the home being a leasing property, a typical house insurance policy is not really adequate. Particular insurance is required to provide defense towards harm and liability as a result of hiring the house. This consists of hiring the whole home and also basically renting out there a room in your own home.

Anonymous said...

goals can be about months individual writer bounce and publication only by look.
One of the day, spell maintaining your equilibrium as you
can rationally disclose yourself into a flashy one. As you get
ahead writer attainment as an high-priced wash or conditioner that is interested in comme il faut a fashionista.Get Best Wholesale Jersey Store
Best Site For Wholesale Jerseys Best Wholesale Jersey Website Best Website For Wholesale Jerseys Best Wholesale NFL Jersey Site Best Wholesale Jersey venture
on a broadcast of tips contains around cracking ideas.
An telling computer network selling advertize is finished points programs.
For monition, if you bought new wear at many big section put in.

sustenance your financial fancy give get the requisite meter to discipline
for voucher or substance codes. This can prevent

Review my site Best Site For Wholesale NFL Jerseys